Phenom.GW
08-08-2010, 05:51 PM
NOTICE: This thread is best viewed inthe "Pulse" Style. Are you using Dark? It is highly recommend you switch as this thread might not look so good in this style.
http://i639.photobucket.com/albums/uu112/PhenomGW/acweb%20sotw/sotw-logo_03.jpg
.....Out of the box (example (http://i639.photobucket.com/albums/uu112/PhenomGW/signature/peachsig.png))
http://i639.photobucket.com/albums/uu112/PhenomGW/acweb%20sotw/sotw-logo_15.jpg
.....Entries:
Sadistic:
http://img812.imageshack.us/img812/1116/acpop.png
didn't keep with the theme.. Seems like a huge mess with no lighting at all. The brushes over the "box" or "signature" are messy. There is no flow. Focal seems squished therefore making it not pleasing to look at. There is a light source in the top left yet the focal's body on the left is shadowed and the focal's body on the right is lit up... therefore either.. he tried to had a light source and had no idea how.. or the light on the right side of the focal was stock. I would say this comes in 3rd place.
arjo112:
http://i32.tinypic.com/307xlxs.png
The focal slants to the left and the whole flow of the signature is to the right so that bugs my right of the bat. There is no color theme... its like a color wheel exploded onto this signature. There is blur in the center of the focal by his waist that bugs me a lot. Font and text placement are bad. However, I do like that he kept with the theme and his signature was actually out of the box. Once again there is no light source. I'll give him 2nd place for keeping with the theme and having an overall cleaner signature than Sadistic.
Begeebuz:
http://img217.imageshack.us/img217/7656/sotw30.png
He wins it for me. I love the effect of the dinosaur holding the signature. He didn't do much for this piece.. the signature inside of the dinosaur is not good imo because its so lit up which makes the focals head extremely hard to look at. The text on the center signature is bad and doesn't fit that signature. The dinosaur is of course some stock image... I doubt he actually created that but.. I love his creativity though so he will definitely recieve first place for me.
http://i639.photobucket.com/albums/uu112/PhenomGW/acweb%20sotw/sotw-logo_11.jpg
Notes: 1) The planning is a little messed up, The votes will be counted on Monday morning at about 11:00 am (GMT+1). Till then you may all vote.
2) Due to this weeks theme not being popular enough, not enough entries are submitted and the judges cannot select a top 5. Therefore all entries are going to the public voting. Judge Golferpro22 was nice enough to give some personal feedback on each entry. Keep in mind this feedback will not effect the public voting results and is only a personal opinion.
http://i639.photobucket.com/albums/uu112/PhenomGW/acweb%20sotw/sotw-logo_03.jpg
.....Out of the box (example (http://i639.photobucket.com/albums/uu112/PhenomGW/signature/peachsig.png))
http://i639.photobucket.com/albums/uu112/PhenomGW/acweb%20sotw/sotw-logo_15.jpg
.....Entries:
Sadistic:
http://img812.imageshack.us/img812/1116/acpop.png
didn't keep with the theme.. Seems like a huge mess with no lighting at all. The brushes over the "box" or "signature" are messy. There is no flow. Focal seems squished therefore making it not pleasing to look at. There is a light source in the top left yet the focal's body on the left is shadowed and the focal's body on the right is lit up... therefore either.. he tried to had a light source and had no idea how.. or the light on the right side of the focal was stock. I would say this comes in 3rd place.
arjo112:
http://i32.tinypic.com/307xlxs.png
The focal slants to the left and the whole flow of the signature is to the right so that bugs my right of the bat. There is no color theme... its like a color wheel exploded onto this signature. There is blur in the center of the focal by his waist that bugs me a lot. Font and text placement are bad. However, I do like that he kept with the theme and his signature was actually out of the box. Once again there is no light source. I'll give him 2nd place for keeping with the theme and having an overall cleaner signature than Sadistic.
Begeebuz:
http://img217.imageshack.us/img217/7656/sotw30.png
He wins it for me. I love the effect of the dinosaur holding the signature. He didn't do much for this piece.. the signature inside of the dinosaur is not good imo because its so lit up which makes the focals head extremely hard to look at. The text on the center signature is bad and doesn't fit that signature. The dinosaur is of course some stock image... I doubt he actually created that but.. I love his creativity though so he will definitely recieve first place for me.
http://i639.photobucket.com/albums/uu112/PhenomGW/acweb%20sotw/sotw-logo_11.jpg
Notes: 1) The planning is a little messed up, The votes will be counted on Monday morning at about 11:00 am (GMT+1). Till then you may all vote.
2) Due to this weeks theme not being popular enough, not enough entries are submitted and the judges cannot select a top 5. Therefore all entries are going to the public voting. Judge Golferpro22 was nice enough to give some personal feedback on each entry. Keep in mind this feedback will not effect the public voting results and is only a personal opinion.