Judge these Sigs!

[Elo]

Here are a few sigs I made. Give me a score, on a scale of 1 to 10. 10 being the best, 1 is the worst.

Sig 1:
http://img118.imageshack.us/img118/4315/elosigkc3.png

Sig 2:
http://img337.imageshack.us/img337/5425/elosig2rc1.png

Personally, I like Sig 1. I really tried on that one.

Thanks in advance for the scores.

If you need a sig made, just post here of what you want in it. Themes, colors, what type of render, etc and I will do my best!

-Elo

[Silent-5]

4.5/5
3.75/5

[Elo]

Well, it was out of 10, but I can do the math rofl

[Silent-5]

sorry :D

[lilnate22]

6/10
7/10


the renders arnt blended in right

[Elo]

I think the top one blends good. I am gonna make more and post them here as I go. Gotta make an album.

I added the red color to the eyes on the second one.

[lilnate22]

no actually the top one is the worst....




2nd one is good

it has a light source

[drappi]

the upper one, 2, the lower one 10

[Silent-5]

Eh i like Upper 1

[szela_93]

i think that graphics is good but i dont like theme

[drappi]

the upper one is alright...the lower one is still much cooler